Jump directly to the page contents

The Strategic Evaluation of the Research Field and their Research Programs

Helmholtz’s research is regularly evaluated by high-ranking international experts. This evaluation takes place in two steps.

In the first step, the scientific evaluation, the panels assess the scientific performance of the research. This review took place between October 2017 and April 2018. Around 600 international experts from 27 countries were involved.

The strategic evaluation, which will take place between September 2019 and February 2020, aims to review the strategic plans of the research field and to propose a basis for the distribution of funding among the programs. Here, too, a high-caliber panel of international recognized experts assess the proposed programs and cross-program activities. The results of the scientific review and the strategic guidelines drawn up in dialogue with the funding bodies - i.e., the Federal Government and the states (Bundesländer), are incorporated into the review process. For this reason, the chairpersons from the scientific evaluations are part of the review panel. The reviewers check whether the research programs are set up correctly and draw up recommendations for the new or realigned Helmholtz programs. These results will be discussed in the Helmholtz Senate. The Senate is made up of external personalities from politics and science. The Helmholtz President chairs the board. The Senate finally adopts funding recommendations on the individual research programs in the coming years.

In the strategic evaluation, the panels review the objectives of the programs with the following questions:

  1. Goals: Are the objectives of the research programs in line with international developments in the respective thematic area? Do they address societal and scientific challenges? Do they fit in with the Helmholtz Mission?
  2. Work Program: Is the program structured in such a way that the objectives are achievable, while leaving room for flexibility? Are the scientific approaches original and the collaborations appropriate and profitable? Are the results of the scientific evaluation taken into account?
  3. Competences and Resources: Are the competences and related resources of the program and its researchers appropriate? Does this give the program the potential for international leadership and groundbreaking research?
  4. Impact and Risks: Will the program have the intended impact in this research field? Could it even be the core for completely new fields of research? Where are the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and risks?

In addition, the experts make specific recommendations for the further development of the research field and its programs and it evaluate the user facilities that Helmholtz offers to researchers from all over the world.

Results strategic evaluation

Strategic Evaluation for Research 2021- 2027

PDF5 MB
Download file

Sören Wiesenfeldt

Head of Department Research
Helmholtz Association

Portraits

  • Earth & Environment

    Marine biologist Mar Fernández Méndez wants to set up large-scale aqua farms of the alga Sargassum, which can capture CO2 from the atmosphere and thus make a significant contribution to climate…

  • Energy

    For months, there has been discussion in Germany and Europe about whether and how synthetic fuels such as e-fuels could be a climate-neutral alternative to gasoline and diesel. We asked our experts…

  • Health

    With BigBrain, they created the most detailed digital model of the human brain. With HIBALL, they are now taking the next step. In an interview, Katrin Amunts from Forschungszentrum Jülich and Alan…

  • Aeronautics, Space and Transport

    In order to make future commercial aircraft even more efficient, a research project that has so far been carried out in Germany is testing aerodynamic limits. But the phenomena are so complex that…

  • Information

    They write seminar papers, scientific articles and can even design experiments. The Office of Technology Assessment has evaluated the consequences of AI chatbots like ChatGPT for education and science…

  • Aeronautics, Space and Transport

    The European Space Agency ESA is sending the largest mission of the decade on its way. The JUICE space probe will search for indications of life on Jupiter's icy moons. That is conceivable, but it is…

As curious as we are? Discover more.